RSS

The downside of factoring

Article Date:  Jan 07 2010
Sue Stedman
Sue Stedman

Sue Stedman, founder of the corporatewear company bearing her name, explains why she’s always avoided invoice factoring.

I recently attended a business seminar where one of the topics being discussed was ‘the benefits of invoice factoring’. The speech really got me wondering why a business would really want to use this type of service.

Being able to draw on your sales invoice prior to receiving payment may seem attractive to those who have an immediate cash flow requirement or may be looking to make a strategic investment without having to meet the bank manager, but in reality, I believe factoring’s long-term effects may be damaging to a small or medium-sized enterprise (SME). 



With the introduction of a factoring company, not only are you creating a barrier between you and your customers with the introduction of the third-party organisation to manage your credit control, but the fees on such services could eat into profit margins and potentially spiral out of control the longer an invoice remains unpaid.

In many businesses, particularly SMEs, people buy people. Hiring a factoring firm to collect your invoices may prove contentious for customers who prefer to deal directly with you on all matters related to the services or products they are purchasing. Plus, some factoring firms actually vet your customers – and your working practices – at the commencement of the relationship.

However good your factoring firm, the fact that you are using one at all will affect your customers’ perceptions of you. The last thing you want is to have a strong cash-flow yet a damaged reputation.



Invoice discounting on the other hand offers the advantage of being able to collect debts and manage credit control in-house, in addition to accessing funds as happens with factoring. Your customers are not made aware of the discounting, although strict rules are typically in place with discounters who will check your credit history, profit track records and typically state that the annual turnover should exceed £500,000 in addition to charging fees and interest on sums provided.

Ultimately, if you have solid and open relationships with your customers, with terms of business agreed in advance and a good joint work ethic, I believe credit control shouldn’t become a sticking point. If your clients are late-paying, find out why and work together to solve the problem.

I would also urge any business owner considering invoice factoring, or even discounting, to do their research first and work out just how much the service will cost their business in the long term. For an SME, strong customer relationships are vital to ongoing success, so outsourcing such critical elements should surely be the last resort.

Comments  [1]

Perry Burns Perry Burns
Friday 8th January 2010

I agree with Sue that factoring can present some severe downstream issues. That is why we have put a group of individuals together to provide a selective invoice discounting service for smaller businesses. They can discount as many or as few invoices as they choose and because the credit assessment is on the basis of the customer, it is open to smaller businesses even if they don’t have half a million of turnover. More information at www.sales101.co.uk/cash101

Report this comment »

Sign up and get...

  • Regular GrowthBusiness newsletters
  • Post comments on articles
Sign up

Trying to raise business finance?

The Vistage Guide to Raising Finance in The New Economy. It tells you what your options are and how best to present your case for business finance. Simply visit www.neweconomyblog.co.uk/rf2 to request your free copy.

Get started with Barclays Business Banking

Choose from 3 great Start-up packages offering a range of business and banking solutions, from cashflow management software (QuickBooks or Sage) to VAT management solution. Plus, up to 2 years FREE banking (conditions apply). Apply online.

Out with the old, in with affordable.

Bring  in IBM System x3650 M2 Express servers powered by Intel® Xeon®  and dramatically lower IT operating expenses. Use  IBM’s online evaluation tool  to see ROI in as little as three months. Find out more

Research

  • What should an AIM company pay its CEO or FD?
    What should a non-executive director or chairman expect to be paid?
    What benchmarks should AIM remuneration committee members be using when
    setting pay?

VCT Special Report 2009

This reports principle aim is to provide business owners seeking funding with information about the amount of funds that VCTs have to invest.

Cash Shells Special Report 2009

A comprehensive overview of cash shells on AIM and PLUS, companies that have become a significant feature on the market landscape.

More

Events Calendar

The Media Magnate Awards 2009

26th March, Vinopolis, London

More

More Analysis: Debt Finance

Scarce credit is restricting growth

The truth about bank lending

Tighter security terms. Higher borrowing costs. Personal guarantees as standard. But don’t worry, the banks are still ‘open for business’. Or are they?

Weighing up asset-based lending

The severe drying up of credit has changed the market for business finance beyond recognition. GB reports on the asset-based lenders who are stepping in where banks now fear to tread

Will government SME loans work?

The first small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are starting to reap the benefits of the government’s £20 billion loan guarantee scheme, announced last month by Peter Mandelson.

Advertisement

Poll

What should Alistair Darling deliver in the Budget?




Have your vote on current issues

People who read this also read

  • Weighing up asset-based lending

    The severe drying up of credit has changed the market for business finance beyond recognition. GB reports on the asset-based lenders who are stepping in where banks now fear to tread
  • Family fortunes

    In tough trading conditions, family businesses are stealing a march on struggling rivals. GB examines how families generate and manage their wealth.
  • Confidence tricks

    British entrepreneurs often admire the American spirit of dauntless optimism, so effectively tapped into by President Obama’s campaign slogan ‘Yes, we can’.
  • The truth about bank lending

    Tighter security terms. Higher borrowing costs. Personal guarantees as standard. But don’t worry, the banks are still ‘open for business’. Or are they?
  • Dog days for manufacturing

    Confidence in the manufacturing sector continues its downward slide, according to research by private equity firm Bowmark Capital.

Active Advisers: Accountant

Active Advisers
Company Name Tel
Sterling Chartered Accountants n/a 020 8515 2929
Silver Levene n/a 020 7383 3200
Cooper Parry 01332 295 544
FW Stephens Michael Cook 020 7362 1820
CLB Coopers David J Travis 0161 245 1000
Clarkson Hyde n/a n/a
Robb Ferguson n/a n/a
Alexander Adrian Berg 0161 832 4841
Haines Watts Chartered Accountants 020 7287 2879
     

White Papers

5 Things You Need to Understand About Your Nexus Footprint

Understand how to monitor your business activities as well as how states enforce Nexus.

ABA Banking Journal

Covers the commercial banking industry in the United States, focusing on a wide variety of banking technologies and solutions.

Accountants World Daily Newsletter

Provides a large collection of relevant news stories that are sourced from over 2,000 different publications daily.

More